Wait... Protein Coffee Is A Thing?!
What Is Protein Coffee and Why Is Everyone Talking About It?
Hey, Beauties. It has come to my attention that not everyone knows about protein coffee—and I’m honestly shaken. Not stirred. Just shaken.
Protein coffee is a blend of brewed coffee and protein powder or shakes, offering a convenient, high-protein boost to start your day. What more can a girl ask for?!
Now, picture this: I’m at the gym, post-workout glow activated, casually ordering a smoothie from the bougie concession stand that my fancy gym overpriced gym has. The guy behind the counter asks what I usually get, and I say, “Oh, I forgot my protein coffee at home.” His face? Confused. Puzzled. Flabbergasted. Like I’d just told him I put SPF on my toes (which, side note, I do).
So naturally, I give this guy the full 411 on what exactly protein iced coffee is. I mean, yeah, it’s exactly what it sounds like, but as someone who's been making it since 2019, I felt the need to share my two cents (that wasn't asked for btw) because I knew all the tips and tricks to make this post-workout hack work best for you.
I'm talking flavor possibilities, formulas, fiber, collagen, you would have thought it wasn't 9:30 and my first meeting wasn't at 10. Then I got home and thought, ‘That guy probably didn’t care one bit—just making conversation for a tip.’ But you know who would care? Who would have use for this latte-level drink that packs up to 50 grams of protein that's literally a 2 for 1? MY BEAUTIES!
Let's dive right into, shall we?
Why Protein Coffee is a Game-Changer
Protein coffee is the unsung hero of the high-protein lifestyle. You’re already drinking coffee—why not make it work harder for you? This combo gives you the same cozy vibes of an iced latte with the power of a full meal in disguise.
It’s especially perfect if:
- You’re on the go – No time for eggs and toast? Coffee’s already in your hand. Just level it up.
- You hate chalky protein shakes – Mixed into coffee and milk, it’s creamy, not clumpy.
- You want to hit your macros easily – Add collagen or fiber and boom, it’s a functional drink.
Whether you’re on a weight loss journey, building muscle, or just trying to stop skipping breakfast, this hack is for you, and here's why!
- Calories: 200–280 kcal depending on the ingredients.
- Protein: 40–45g total, especially with add-ins like collagen peptides.
- Convenience: Premade shakes or powdered protein make prep fast.
- Customizable: Add syrups, spices, or use seasonal flavors for variety.
The Base Players – Build Your Brew
When it comes to building the base of your protein coffee, you’ve got two solid routes: premade shakes or protein powder. I personally love a good no-brainer base like the Equate High Performance Vanilla or Quest shakes. They’re clutch when you’re on the go—no mixing, no measuring, just pop the cap and pour. Plus, they actually taste pretty great. Other solid choices in this lane include Fairlife, OWYN, or anything that fits your taste and macros.
If you’ve got a little more time and you’re feeling fancy, flavored or unflavored protein powders open the door to endless customization. I recommend unflavored powder if you want the freedom to control sweetness and taste—it’s usually lower in calories and lets you play barista with zero-calorie syrups like Torani or Jordan's Skinny Syrups. If you already have a flavored protein you love, go for it—it’s basically your favorite Starbucks drink right in your kitchen once mixed right.
I’ve also been experimenting with True Nutrition flavor packs (you can buy them in small 50g or 100g packs to test drive the flavors). Quick rundown of ones I’ve tried:
- Banana Crème: Honestly, a little too banana-y for me.
- Toasted Coconut: Chef’s kiss. Smooth, subtle, and tropical.
- Maple Pecan: Tastes like a fall latte. So cozy!
There are plenty more flavors to try, so mix and match to your heart’s content.
TL;DR: Your protein coffee base can be grab-n-go or totally DIY—but either way, it should taste like it’s judging Starbucks from afar with a protein halo over its head. ☕💪
Do I Have a Foolproof Recipe? Of Course, I Do!
Would I even be me if I didn’t have a go-to recipe tucked away just for my beauties?? No I would not!
I went through six grueling years of trial and error to get this recipe right—and honestly, it's still not done. The constant moving pieces and finding new elements to make protein iced coffee even better is a contant. Maybe by the time I post this blog, there’ll probably be an amendment, lol.
Now, before we jump into this, I like cold brew, but regular brew that's been chilled, shots of espresso, and instant are perfect subs. I've tried them all and they're fanstatic! However, the best flavor by far, to me, is cold brew, with 2 shots of espresso being a close second.
✨ Balanced Beauty Signature Iced Protein Coffee ✨
- ½ cup homemade cold brew (or store-bought if you’re not in the barista mood)
- 1 scoop of flavored protein powder (Industry Standard: 170 cals, 2.5g fat, 30g protein)
- ½ cup Fairlife 2% milk (or your fav high-protein milk)
- 2 tbsp Vital Proteins Collagen Peptides (30 cals, 9g protein)
- 1 scoop Equate Clear Soluble Fiber Powder (for that ~gut health~ moment)
- Lots of ice
- Optional: a splash of water if it’s a little too thick for your vibe
Use an electric whisk to evenly disperse any powder you add in because these blender bottles just aren't what they used to be.
Nutrition📖
As you can see, my recipe has ~19g of carbs, including 5g of fiber—meaning only 14g net carbs if you’re tracking closely. Most of the carbs/sugar comes from the protein powder and milk. For someone who is low-carb/Keto, this recipe can easily be lower to ~5 net carbs by swapping out the Fairlife for an unsweetened plant milk like Silk Almond and going for a premade shake, which are typically 2–3g net carbs or simply using an unflavored protein powder as your base.
Flavor Options😋
How could I ever forget about the unflavored powder girlies? I know the only reason you chose that route is because you're indecisive and can't commit to a single flavor. Me too, babe. Here are some of my favorite coffee syrup combos that'll level up that protein iced coffee!
Lavender Vanilla Cloud 🌸✨
Tastes like: A floral, calming treat with creamy vanilla notes
- 2 pumps Sugar-Free Lavender (DaVinci or Monin)
- 2 pumps Sugar-Free French Vanilla (Torani or Matteo’s)
Cookie Butter Dream ☁️🍪
Tastes like: A fresh-baked spiced butter cookie
- 2 pumps Sugar-Free Brown Sugar Cinnamon (Torani or DaVinci)
- 1 pump Sugar-Free Butter Toffee (Jordan's Skinny Syrups)
- 1 pump Sugar-Free Vanilla (any brand)
Caramel Mocha Macchiato 🍫🍯
Tastes like:A chocolatey caramel swirl
- 2 pumps Sugar-Free Chocolate Syrup (Matteo’s or Jordan's Skinny Syrups)
- 1 pump Sugar-Free Caramel (Torani or DaVinci)
- 1 pump Sugar-Free Vanilla (balances out the flavors)
Now listen—this is *my* go-to combo, but your perfect iced protein coffee might look a little different. That’s the beauty of it.
Play around with the syrups, switch up the protein flavors, try oat milk instead of Fairlife if that’s your vibe. The possibilities are endless and there are no wrong answers… unless you skip the collagen. Then we might have words.
So there you have it—the Balanced Beauty signature brew, complete with flavor inspo and all the extras your heart (and gut) could want. I usually take it with me for my post-workout snack.
Quick fun fact: A lot of people think your anabolic window is exactly 3 seconds after you rerack, but your really have three hours to get your protein in post-workout. So breathe, girl, and get that protein bar out of your gym sock. Whether you’re rushing to a morning meeting or need to refuel after slamming weights around for an hour and a half, this is your solution. So, sip on pretty, protein princess 💅☕✨
Final Thought: Sip Smart, Live Balanced
Let’s be real—you don’t have to sacrifice flavor to reach your fitness goals. With a little creativity (and maybe a few syrups), your morning coffee can be the highlight of your day and the healthiest thing you do.
Most of us need about 120g of protein daily, and by the time you do the quick math, it's the end of the day and you're still down 35g. This any time drink gets 1/3 of your daily protein needs without even thinking twice about
Adding protein to your coffee isn’t just a gym rat trend—it’s a lifestyle hack. Whether you’re chasing gains, trying to hit your macros, or just hate the idea of bland, chalky shakes, this brew has your back. It's creamy, dreamy, and packs enough protein to make your future self proud.
And let’s be honest: your iced coffee is already a non-negotiable, so why not make it work a little harder for you? It’s your daily self-care moment in a tumbler. A lil' hydration with a lotta satisfaction, and a splash of flex all in one sip.
Is protein iced coffee on your try list? Spill in the comments! 💬👇🏽
✨ Flavor tip: Obsessed with dessert-inspired drinks? My Iced Cookie Butter Latte is a low-cal dream come true—and you can totally turn it into an iced protein latte too!
0 comments